機器說正常的LAD閉塞
是什麼: Pendell Meyers(OMI概念共同創立者)在Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格)11-13發表:一位40多歲男性急性胸痛叫救護車,EMS在胸痛當下記錄的心電圖,機器只提到59次/分的竇性心搏過緩,其餘判為「正常」。1 Meyers強烈不同意,認為這張幾乎可確診LAD完全閉塞:V1–V3缺血性ST抬高(未達STEMI標準)、R波很小,V2、V3、V4、I、aVL超急性T波,V6 ST壓低構成precordial swirl,III與aVF有對應性ST壓低。1
為什麼要在意: 團隊在不符STEMI標準的情況下啟動導管室,心臟科「不覺得有什麼」但沒有取消;結果是LAD完全閉塞的罪犯病灶,door-to-balloon不到60分鐘。1 如果當時等第一個troponin,它會是正常的7 ng/L(高敏感度troponin I,男性參考上限<20);之後兩次都超過25,000 ng/L。1 Smith補充一個他必看的特異徵象:懷疑V2超急性T波時,找III或aVF的先下後上T波,這例aVF就有。1 單一病例 · 專家判讀 · 教學級
Smith也提到,他在部落格累積65例傳統演算法判為完全正常、但實為OMI的心電圖,用來測試PMcardio Queen of Hearts,敏感度81%;這是他自己團隊的資料,不是本例的結果。1 利益揭露: Meyers與Smith持有Queen of Hearts開發商Powerful Medical的股份,本篇部落格文中未見揭露。2
Ken Grauer(KG-EKG Press,佛州ECG教學)的評論說,知道病人是急性胸痛後,他不到10秒就看出V1–V3超急性T波、V5–V6 ST變平略壓低,以及下壁對應性ST壓低。3
所以呢: 本刊觀點:台灣的到院前心電圖多半直接傳到急診,常附著機器判讀;這例提醒的是「機器說正常」只代表沒有達到演算法門檻。胸痛當下的心電圖,急診醫師要自己看T波大小與QRS的比例、V6、以及下壁的對應性變化,再決定是否啟動導管室;床邊超音波看到前壁室壁運動異常,也能作為佐證。1
正常心電圖加陰性troponin
是什麼: 醫學生Jack Cahill在Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格)11-09發表、Willy Frick(WashU心臟科)與Smith編修:一位50多歲女性,有高血壓與兩次暫時性腦缺血病史,胸痛24小時就診,血壓約170/100。4 第一張心電圖看起來沒有異常,兩次高敏感度troponin相隔僅50分鐘、都「陰性」,於是以疑似胃食道逆流讓她回家。4
為什麼要在意: 5小時後她因「無法忍受」的胸痛回來,第二張心電圖出現相對QRS過大的超急性T波,以V4最明顯,Smith另指出V4新的Q波;作者判讀為可診斷急性LAD閉塞,但當時沒有被當成STEMI/OMI處理。4 回診後第一個troponin I是250 ng/L,下一次隔了12小時才驗,已升到48,000 ng/L。4 隔天冠狀動脈攝影是第IV型(繞過心尖的)LAD,TIMI 3血流,中段管徑突然變窄,疑似自發性冠狀動脈剝離(SCAD);心臟超音波則是心尖氣球樣變化。4 單一病例 · 專家意見 · 教學級
這例有兩個陷阱。一是心尖氣球樣變化很像takotsubo,但作者強調冠狀動脈攝影之前不能診斷takotsubo;Smith也說48,000 ng/L的troponin對takotsubo來說太高。4 二是「陰性」troponin:Smith認為唯一真正陰性的是測不到的troponin,應該寫出確切數值與單位。4 文中也有Queen of Hearts的判讀圖;利益揭露: Smith持有其開發商Powerful Medical的股份,本篇部落格文中未見揭露。5
Ken Grauer(KG-EKG Press,佛州ECG教學)指出,第一張心電圖雖然不具診斷性,但對胸痛病人來說也不是「正常」:V3的ST變直,V4有細微的J點壓低;並重申單一張心電圖不足以排除急性OMI。6
所以呢: Smith的做法是:心電圖可疑但不具診斷性時,每15分鐘一張心電圖、每30分鐘一次troponin。4 本刊觀點:不論醫院用哪一種快速troponin流程,這例的兩次抽血只隔50分鐘、病歷也沒寫數值;離院前至少要有第二張心電圖並和第一張逐導程比,交班與病歷寫出試劑、數值與單位。
OnScene:直升機上的ECPR
是什麼: OnScene由Reis Miranda等發表於NEJM(新英格蘭醫學期刊)11-07線上版:荷蘭全國、非隨機研究,比較配備院前ECPR能力的直升機EMS與沒有ECPR能力的直升機EMS,對象是50歲以下的難治性到院前心跳停止,主要結果是出院存活。7 EMCrit(重症急診)的EM Nerd專欄11-10補充設計細節:這是四個直升機站的階梯式(stepped-wedge)設計,納入18至50歲、有目擊、從直升機派遣起超過20分鐘仍未恢復的心跳停止,初始節律為VF/VT,或懷疑肺栓塞造成的PEA。8
為什麼要在意: 介入組144人中57人(40%)出院存活,對照組87人中17人(20%),OR 2.72(95% CI 1.59–4.66);6個月神經學預後良好為36% vs 13%(OR 4.22,95% CI 2.82–6.32)。7 介入組到ECMO血流的中位時間是45分鐘,對照組在院內接受ECPR者是77分鐘。8 非隨機 · 階梯式 · n=231 · 假說級
EM Nerd的批評集中在設計:站別轉換順序沒有隨機,介入組60%病人來自同一站(鹿特丹),該站是訓練者與有ECMO經驗醫師所在;是否納入由已經知道自己有沒有ECMO能力的團隊在現場判斷;介入組VF比例較高(89% vs 75%),神經學預後由一位未盲化的研究者評估。8 他提醒,在復甦醫學中,非隨機研究顯示存活加倍的紀錄並不好,機械式CPR與阻抗閥都曾有前後比較研究顯示存活改善,之後的隨機試驗卻沒有證實。8
所以呢: 本刊觀點:這篇改變的是「年輕、目擊、可電擊節律的難治性OHCA值得盡早評估ECPR」的討論力道,而不是證明院前ECPR一定有效。台灣多數ECPR是在病人送到醫院後啟動;急診端能做的是預先定義ECPR候選條件與啟動流程,縮短到ECMO血流的時間,並等隨機試驗的結果。
Shark-fin不是診斷
是什麼: Avidan等(共同作者含Stephen W. Smith,Hennepin Healthcare,OMI主軸)在Heart Rhythm(心律期刊)11-11線上發表系統性回顧:shark-fin型態常被連結到阻塞性冠狀動脈疾病,作者搜尋到2026-05-20、有個別病人資料的文獻。9 最後納入85篇、104位病人,66.3%是非阻塞性病因。9
為什麼要在意: 冠狀動脈疾病組幾乎都是男性(97.1%),罪犯血管75%是左主幹或近端LAD,shark-fin出現的導程與冠狀動脈解剖相符的比例是91.4%;VT/VF與死亡各37.1%,而且不良結果只出現在左主幹/LAD病灶的病人。9 其他病因以女性為主(60.8%),最常見的是takotsubo(31.7%)、冠狀動脈痙攣(14.4%)、心肌炎(6.7%)、神經急症(4.8%);這組VT/VF為43.4%,死亡27.5%。9 資料來自病例報告彙整,發表偏差難免。PubMed紀錄未附利益衝突聲明(待確認)。 系統性回顧 · 病例報告彙整 · n=104 · 假說級
所以呢: 作者結論是shark-fin是高風險心電圖型態、不是診斷,需要緊急找病因並做心電監視。9 本刊觀點:在急診看到shark-fin,先貼上去顫電極片、上監視器,同時啟動冠狀動脈評估;但如果導管室沒看到阻塞,不要因此降低警覺,摘要中takotsubo病人63.6%出現VT/VF或死亡、痙攣病人66%出現心室性心律不整,並不比冠狀動脈組低。9
延伸與出處
本週其他值得注意的標題
Precordial swirl的心肌基質: Emre Aslanger(伊斯坦堡OMI共同作者)等在Journal of Electrocardiology(心電圖期刊)11-05線上發表:105位第一次前壁STEMI、成功初級PCI後3–7天做心臟磁振造影的病人,22位(21.0%)有precordial swirl型態(V1–V2 ST抬高合併V5及/或V6 ST壓低)。10 這組的晚期釘增強穿壁程度較低;LAD閉塞在第一中隔支近端的比例兩組相近(36.4% vs 36.6%),作者認為swirl可能反映穿壁與心內膜下損傷的混合,而不只是近端LAD閉塞。10 本刊觀點:這是機轉研究,不改變急診處置:swirl仍是LAD閉塞的心電圖徵象。
超急性T波測驗: Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格)11-09刊出Ahmed Marai製作的30題超急性T波與其模仿者測驗,作答後立即給分數與附詳解的PDF;文中說Queen of Hearts與Smith都答對30題(Smith持有其開發商Powerful Medical股份)。115 適合當住院醫師的自我測驗。
誰這週有新作
Pendell Meyers與Jack Cahill各寫一則Smith部落格病例(卡1、卡2),Ken Grauer兩篇都有評論;Smith是shark-fin系統性回顧的共同作者(卡4),Aslanger發表swirl的心臟磁振研究。Jesse McLaren、Willy Frick本週範圍內沒有新的PubMed文章;快取中較早的文章本刊先前已介紹,不再重複。
引用
Meyers HP,Smith SW編修,〈A man in his 40s with chest pain and "normal findings" per EMS machine read〉,Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格),2026-11-13。原文:「The EMS machine algorithm lead mentions the sinus bradycardia at 59 bpm」;「I think it is ~100% diagnostic of acute total LAD occlusion. Ischemic STE in V1-V3 (less than STEMI criteria), poor R waves there, and HATW in V2, V3, V4, I, aVL. Precordial swirl pattern is completed by the STD in V6.」;「Sure enough, there is a down-up T-wave in aVF.」;「it would have been within normal limits at 7 ng/L (high sensitivity troponin I, URL <20 for men)」;「documented a total LAD occlusive culprit lesion」;「The door to balloon time was under 60 minutes!」;「The next two troponins were both greater than 25,000 ng/L.」;「I have 65 cases of OMI on this blog for which the conventional algorithm says the ECG is totally normal」;「She was 81% sensitive for OMI.」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎
Aslanger EK等,〈Occlusion-Focused Triage vs Very-High-Risk NSTEMI Criteria: A DIFOCCULT-3 Substudy〉,JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions(JACC心血管介入),2026-10-12(PMID 42863867),利益衝突聲明。原文:「Drs Meyers and Smith hold stock in Powerful Medical.」。跳到原文 ↩︎
Grauer K,評論(2026-11-13),收於〈A man in his 40s with chest pain and "normal findings" per EMS machine read〉,Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格)。原文:「it literally took me less than 10 seconds on learning that this patient has acute onset CP」;「Hyperacute T waves in leads V1,V2,V3 + ST segment flattening with slight depression in leads V5,V6」;「there is reciprocal ST depression in the inferior leads」。跳到原文 ↩︎
Cahill J,Frick W、Smith SW編修,〈A 50-year-old with a normal ECG and troponin – Safe or Sorry? –so many learning points on this one〉,Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格),2026-11-09。原文:「A woman in her 50s, with hypertension, osteoarthritis, asthma, vitamin D deficiency and two previous transient ischaemic attacks」;「presented to the Emergency Department with 24 hours of chest pain」;「marked hypertension (BP ~ 170/100)」;「Two high-sensitivity troponin assays were taken — only 50 minutes apart, both were "negative".」;「The only truly "negative" troponin is one that is undetectable. One should always report the exact values and the units.」;「She returned to the ED 5 hours later with ongoing "unbearable" chest pain.」;「These are hyperacute T waves, most prominent in V4」;「there is also a new Q-wave in lead V4」;「her initial troponin I returned at 250 ng/L」;「The repeat, not measured until 12 hours later (!) rose dramatically to 48,000 ng/L」;「Type IV LAD, TIMI 3 flow, with an abrupt step-change in vessel calibre within the mid-vessel, suggestive of SCAD」;「Angiography must always be performed before diagnosing takotsubo.」;「The troponin of 48,000 is far too high for takotsubo.」;「I will get serial ECGs every 15 minutes and serial trop every 30 minutes.」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎
Smith SW、de Alencar JN,〈The Unlucky Occlusion Patients Missed by the STEMI/NSTEMI Paradigm May Be Found by OMI/NOMI〉,JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions(JACC心血管介入),2026-10-12(PMID 42863866),利益衝突聲明。原文:「Dr Smith holds stock in Powerful Medical, maker of the PMCardio Queen of Hearts AI ECG Model.」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎
Grauer K,評論(2026-11-09),收於〈A 50-year-old with a normal ECG and troponin – Safe or Sorry?〉,Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格)。原文:「the initial ECG in today's case is non-diagnostic. But in the context of a patient who presents to the ED for chest pain — the initial ECG is not "normal".」;「lead V3 instead manifests ST segment straightening」;「subtle-but-real J-point ST depression」;「a single ECG is not sufficient to rule out acute OMI」。跳到原文 ↩︎
Reis Miranda D、Moors X、Ali S等、Gommers D,〈Prehospital Extracorporeal Life Support in Refractory Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest〉,N Engl J Med(新英格蘭醫學期刊),2026-11-07線上(PMID 43001740)。原文:「In a nationwide, nonrandomized study conducted in the Netherlands」;「In the intervention group, 57 of 144 patients (40%) survived until hospital discharge, as compared with 17 of 87 patients (20%) in the conventional group (odds ratio, 2.72; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.59 to 4.66; P = 0.002).」;「a favorable neurologic outcome was reported in 51 of 141 patients (36%) in the intervention group and in 11 of 85 patients (13%) in the conventional group (odds ratio, 4.22; 95% CI, 2.82 to 6.32)」;「incorporating ECPR into HEMS was associated with improved survival until hospital discharge」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎
EM Nerd,〈The Scene of Four〉,EMCrit(重症急診),2026-11-10。原文:「OnScene was a nationwide, non-randomized, stepped-wedge study conducted across four Dutch Helicopter Emergency Medical Services (HEMS) stations.」;「Patients aged 18 to 50 with a witnessed refractory arrest, defined as an arrest lasting more than 20 minutes from HEMS dispatch」;「Median time to ECMO flow was 45 minutes in the intervention group, compared with 77 minutes among conventional patients who received in-hospital ECPR.」;「Sixty percent of the intervention patients came from a single station, Rotterdam, which housed the study's trainers and all HEMS physicians with prior ECMO experience.」;「Eligibility was decided on scene, after the HEMS team arrived, by a crew that already knew whether they had ECMO capability.」;「Ventricular fibrillation accounted for 89% of the intervention group and 75% of the conventional group.」;「Neurologic outcomes were scored by a single unblinded investigator.」;「in resuscitation, a nonrandomized doubling of survival has a poor track record」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎
Avidan Y、Arena R、Atwan H、Schliamser JE、Smith SW、Danon A、Weizman B,〈Beyond Coronary Artery Disease: Etiologies and Outcomes of the Shark-Fin ECG Pattern: A Systematic Review〉,Heart Rhythm(心律期刊),2026-11-11線上(PMID 43014630)。原文:「We systematically reviewed PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, and Cochrane from inception through May 20, 2026」;「Eighty-five papers involving 104 patients were included; 66.3% had non-obstructive etiologies.」;「The obstructive CAD patients were predominantly male (97.1%), while other etiologies were predominantly female (60.8%).」;「the left main coronary artery (LMCA)/proximal left anterior descending artery (LAD) was the culprit in 75.0%, and SFS localization matched coronary anatomy in 91.4%. VT/VF and death each occurred in 37.1%, with adverse outcomes confined to those with LMCA/LAD lesions.」;「Takotsubo syndrome (TTS, 31.7%), vasospasm (14.4%), myocarditis (6.7 %) and neurologic emergencies (4.8%)」;「VT/VF occurred in 43.4% and 27.5% died.」;「Among patients with TTS, 63.6% experienced VT/VF or death, compared with ventricular arrhythmias in 66% of patients with vasospasm.」;「SFS is a high-risk ECG pattern rather than a diagnosis and warrants urgent etiologic evaluation and cardiac monitoring.」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎ ↩︎
Aslanger EK、de Alencar JN、Gençol Akçay G等、Değertekin M,〈Swirling vectors: The myocardial substrate of the precordial swirl pattern in anterior myocardial infarction〉,Journal of Electrocardiology(心電圖期刊),2026-11-05線上(PMID 43002909)。原文:「We analyzed 105 prospectively enrolled patients with first anterior ST-elevation MI treated with successful primary percutaneous coronary intervention and cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) 3-7 days later.」;「The precordial swirl phenotype was defined as ST elevation in V1-V2 with ST depression in V5 and/or V6.」;「Twenty-two patients (21.0%) had the phenotype.」;「Proximal-to-S1 occlusion was similar (36.4% vs 36.6%; P = 1.000).」;「Precordial swirl was associated with less transmural LGE, without detectable enrichment for proximal-to-S1 occlusion or greater septal injury」。跳到原文 ↩︎ ↩︎
Smith SW,〈Hyperacute T-wave Quiz. 30 ECG cases.〉,Dr. Smith's ECG Blog(Smith心電圖部落格),2026-11-09。原文:「It was created by Dr. Ahmed Marai」;「Both the PMcardio Queen of Hearts and Dr. Smith got 30/30 correct.」;「After the quiz, you will immediately get your score and a link to a pdf of all the cases, explained in detail.」。跳到原文 ↩︎